The Theme from New York, New York was performed for the first time since Decem(772 shows) and featured the naked dude dancers performing a kickline in front of the stage while adding vocals and Trey changing the lyrics to 'if I could be naked there.' Page teased Tweezer in Caspian. Carini featured several dancers in 'naked dude' costumes emerging from a birthday cake in front of the stage and dancing and running around with security trying to catch them. During Auld Lang Syne, Phish briefly stopped playing and ate cake in front of the stage while the marching band and choir continued to perform. Only the final verse was sung in Wilson which contained Jungle Boogie quotes and was unfinished. Inflated Wilson volleyballs were then tossed into the crowd. The marching band and choir were also featured in Wilson where a platform above Trey that had appeared for the entire New Year's run descended and the clone that had been lying on the platform rose and was revealed to be a Tom Hanks actor from Cast Away. The first Jungle Boogie since Decem(544 shows) featured the BD Entertainment Marching Band marching band along with the choir. The first Bohemian Rhapsody since Decem(850 shows) featured the Late Show Gospel Choir singing on risers behind the band and Ghost quotes from Page and the choir with subsequent lyrics changed to reference Ghost. Ghost featured Meatstick lyrics sung from the band as well as by dancers in different languages in a nod to December 31, 2010. The wombat broke the time machine and Ghost began with dancers and characters (like Father Time from Decemand the Famous Mockingbird from December 31, 1992) continuing to appear from the band's past performances. Dancers from various past new year's gags appeared on stage as well as a wombat (from October 31, 2013). The quartet activated the time machine and the cube played audio and video from past years of Phish. A cube descended from overhead and a time machine was revealed near Mike. Trey wished he had a time machine so they could do it all again.

The telegram said that at the stroke of midnight it would be 40 years for Phish and to make a wish. Before the third set began, a barbershop quartet appeared with a singing telegram for Phish. The second setbreak music was comprised of songs referencing past Phish New Year's Eve gags. Page teased The Little Drummer Boy in the first Tweezer.

Encore bet music